A concert with friends, a cooking class abroad or a weekend in the mountains tends to bring more lasting happiness than a new gadget of the same price. That is the conclusion of more than a decade of research by Cornell psychologist Thomas Gilovich and his colleagues, and it points to four clear reasons why experiences are often the better buy.

Spending money on experiences, not possessions – lead photograph

The research on experiences and happiness

The idea was put to the test in 2003, when Leaf Van Boven of the University of Colorado and Gilovich published "To Do or to Have? That Is the Question" in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. In a national survey of more than 12,000 Americans, people were asked to recall one experiential and one material purchase made to increase their happiness. Most said the experience had made them happier. In laboratory studies, students who thought about an experiential purchase reported better moods than those who thought about a material one.

Later Cornell studies with Amit Kumar and Matthew Killingsworth explored why. Their findings form the four reasons below.

Four reasons to spend money on experiences

1. Memories get better with time

Experiences can be reinterpreted. A rainy hiking trip becomes, in memory, a challenge you overcame together. A possession stays "out there", separate from you. Van Boven summed it up: people "receive more enduring pleasure and satisfaction from investing in life experiences".

2. Experiences are made for sharing

In 2013 Kumar and Gilovich reported that people talk about their experiences far more than about their possessions, and that this talk explains much of the extra satisfaction. In one experiment with 98 participants, people who recalled an experience were more willing to give it up for a lesser one they could talk about. Take away the chance to tell the story, and an experience loses much of its glow; a possession does not.

3. Anticipation is part of the pleasure

The 2014 paper "Waiting for Merlot", published in Psychological Science by Gilovich, Kumar and Killingsworth, found that people waiting for an experience, such as a ski pass or concert tickets, were happier than people waiting for a material purchase. In newspaper reports of crowds queuing, those waiting for experiences were in better moods and behaved better than shoppers queuing for goods. The enjoyment of a trip starts the day you book it.

4. Experiences become part of who you are

We are the sum of what we have done more than of what we own. Experiences tie into personal goals, accomplishments and meaning, and they usually involve other people. As Van Boven put it, "Experiences foster relationships because you tend to do things with other people", and relationships are closely linked to happiness.

How to choose experiences that pay off

  • Start with the purpose. Decide whether you want time with someone, a new skill or a change of scene, then pick the activity.
  • Book ahead. Since anticipation adds to the pleasure, planning early lets you enjoy the wait.
  • Go with others. Shared experiences give you stories and stronger bonds.
  • Try a small version first. A single class or a local day out can be as memorable as a long trip; see our free activities for a day out.
  • Keep it affordable. Count transport, food and time off as well as the ticket, so the memory is not spoiled by the bill.
  • Tell the story. Keep a photo or a journal entry, and talk about it afterwards.

Possessions still have their place, especially ones that make experiences possible, such as a bicycle, a tent or an instrument. Gilovich's own advice is to find "the right mix of material and experiential consumption" for your well-being. For a trip already on the calendar, read about enjoying the preparation.

Related reading

Sources