In 2014 a GoPro video titled "GoPro: Man Fights Off Great White Shark In Sydney Harbour" raced around the internet. It seemed to show a man jumping into the water and coming face to face with a great white. Two years later, the Melbourne production studio The Woolshed Co. revealed that it had made the clip, along with seven other viral hits, as a deliberate experiment.

An underwater frame from the staged Sydney shark GoPro video
An underwater frame from the staged Sydney shark GoPro video. Gallery attribution: The Woolshed Company.

The Woolshed Co. and its viral video experiment

The studio went public in July 2016, as reported by ABC News. Over two years, its team produced eight fake videos that together drew more than 205 million views in 180 countries, without paid media, promotion or publicity.

The Sydney shark video came first, and the studio paid for it itself. Managing director Dave Christison described it as "really just an organic kind of experiment to see, can we make some noise in the viral world?" He added that "there was nothing ever sinister or malicious behind this experiment."

The aim was to understand what makes a video spread, to learn how to promote films and win commercial work, and to develop message-based campaigns for not-for-profit groups. Christison also pointed out that debate over whether the clips were real was itself part of what drove interest.

The other fake viral videos

After the shark clip and a commercially funded video of a man taking a selfie with a tornado, the studio received support from Screen Australia's Multiplatform Drama Fund for six more productions. The titles revealed in 2016 included:

  • GoPro: Man Fights Off Great White Shark In Sydney Harbour
  • Snowboarder Girl Chased By Bear
  • Lightning almost strikes girl in Sydney
  • USA vs JAPAN: Ultimate Selfie Stick Fight
  • GoPro Falls Off Drone Into Burning Man Dance Floor
  • the tornado selfie video

How to spot a staged viral video

The shark clip worked because it used the language of real footage: a shaky first-person camera, a sudden warning and only a brief glimpse of the animal. A few habits help when a dramatic clip lands in your feed:

  • Find the first upload. Note the channel, the date and whether the uploader has a history of similar "lucky" footage.
  • Look for follow-up reporting. Search the title with words such as "fake", "staged" or "creators". In this case, the answer arrived two years later from the makers themselves.
  • Ask who benefits. A clip that names a brand or camera in its title is often built to be shared.
  • Check for named witnesses. A real shark encounter in a busy harbour would usually produce local news reports, witnesses or a statement from authorities.

Great white sharks in Australian waters

The real great white shark is impressive enough without special effects. Adult females mature at around 4.6 to 4.9 metres long and typically weigh 1,000 to 1,900 kilograms; males mature at 3.4 to 4 metres. Australia has major populations, and Bass Strait separates genetically distinct eastern and western groups. The eastern Australia and New Zealand population is estimated at 2,500 to 6,750 animals.

Bites on humans are rare. Great whites are responsible for 351 documented unprovoked bites since 1580, 59 of them fatal. The species is listed as vulnerable worldwide and has been protected under Australian federal law since 1999. On Sydney's beaches, swim between the red and yellow flags, where lifeguards are watching.

For a real cliff-jumping film, see Cliff Jumping Hawaii – Proof: Devinsupertramp’s Film and Lele Kawa, and for genuine first-person travel footage, Five Seconds a Day: A Motorcycle Journey Through Thirteen European Countries.

Sources